Korisnik:Antidiskriminator/Pesak – razlika između verzija

Uklonjeni sadržaj Dodani sadržaj
pesak
→‎rsn: pesak
Red 106:
:# ''RSN rejected magazine as reliable sources about Vojsava''. One user approached [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reliable_sources/Noticeboard/Archive_94#Help_needed RSN] and asked for opinion about reliability of one magazine which published the information with Schmitt's claim about Vojsava's ethnicity. That source was rejected and declared as not reliable. The explanation was:"''don't use the magazine, use his book as the source''".
:# "Gazeta Albania non-authorized interview" published on January 24, 2009 contradicts everything Schmitt wrote in his books or said in his interviews published before or after this interview. Also, there was an authorized interview given a month later, published in (reputable and completely neutral) [[Switzerland|Swiss]] national daily newspaper [[Tagesanzeiger]]. In that interview in which it is emphasized that Schmitt claims that Skanderbeg's mother [[Vojsava Kastrioti|Vojsava]] was Serbian, member of [[Brankovići]] and that Kastrioti surname is probably derived from the Greek word.({{Citation |last=Robelli |first=Enver |author= |authorlink= |coauthors= |firstn=,lastn=,authorn= |author-separator= |editor= |editorn= |editorn-last= |editorn-first= |editor-link= |editorn-link= |others= |title= Schweizer Historiker weckt den Ärger der Albaner |url=http://www.tagesanzeiger.ch/kultur/buecher/Schweizer-Historiker-beleidigt-Albaner/story/19392466?print=yes%20Robelli%20Enver%20(2009)%20Schweiger%20Historiker%20weckt%20den%20%C4%80rger%20der%20Albaner,%20%20 |archiveurl= |archivedate= |format= |accessdate= |edition= |series= |volume= |date=25 |origyear= |year=2009 |month=February |publisher= [[Tagesanzeiger]] |location= Switzerland |language= German |isbn= |oclc= |doi= |doi_inactivedate= |bibcode= |id= |page= |pages= |nopp= |at= |chapter= |chapterurl= |quote=Skanderbegs '''Mutter Vojsava war eine Serbin''' aus der einflussreichen Familie Brankovic. Der Name des Stammes Kastrioti leitet sich laut Schmitt vermutlich vom griechischen Wort «kastron» (Festung) ab |laysummary= |laydate= |separator= |postscript= |lastauthoramp= |ref= }})
 
:Maybe I should rephrase my question:
:Taking in consideration that ZjarriRrethues:
:# used magazine as source
:##(ignoring [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reliable_sources/Noticeboard/Archive_94#Help_needed RSN] which clearly concluded: "''don't use the magazine, use his book as the source''")
:##(ignoring consensus to create section presenting "different historians' opinions on the question of Vojsava's ethnicity""
:# to add "seriously over-simplified" information [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Tendentious_editing#One_whose_citations_are_inadequate.2C_ambiguous_or_not_sufficiently_explicit ]
:# not about Vojsava but about her son, Skanderbeg (again ignoring [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reliable_sources/Noticeboard/Archive_94#Help_needed RSN] and numerous comments on the talk page which emphasized that it is important to avoid WP:SYNTH)
:was maybe potentially slightly a little bit involved in disruptive behaviour?
 
:Please before you answer above mentioned question take in consideration that he already:
:#