Razlike između izmjena na stranici "Razgovor sa korisnikom:Dcirovic"

 
: {{ping|Te750iv}} In such cases redirect should point to the corresponding disambiguation page. --[[Korisnik:Dcirovic|Dcirovic]] ([[Razgovor sa korisnikom:Dcirovic|razgovor]]) 21:22, 1 decembar 2018 (CET)
 
== deletion request: fantasy location redirects ==
Hi again, I noticed that you removed deletion requests and kept the following 30 pages as redirects to the disambiguation [[Halle]] (example [https://sh.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Halle,_bei_Neuenhaus,_Saksonija-Anhalt&diff=next&oldid=40865005 here]):
#[[Halle, bei Neuenhaus, Saksonija-Anhalt]]
#[[Hale, bei Neuenhaus, Saksonija-Anhalt]]
#[[Хале, bei Neuenhaus, Saksonija-Anhalt]]
#[[Halle (bei Neuenhaus, Saksonija-Anhalt)]]
#[[Hale (bei Neuenhaus, Saksonija-Anhalt)]]
#[[Хале (bei Neuenhaus, Saksonija-Anhalt)]]
#[[Halle, bei Neuenhaus, Саксонија-Анхалт]]
#[[Hale, bei Neuenhaus, Саксонија-Анхалт]]
#[[Хале, bei Neuenhaus, Саксонија-Анхалт]]
#[[Halle (bei Neuenhaus, Саксонија-Анхалт)]]
#[[Hale (bei Neuenhaus, Саксонија-Анхалт)]]
#[[Хале (bei Neuenhaus, Саксонија-Анхалт)]]
#[[Halle, bei Neuenhaus, Sachsen-Anhalt]]
#[[Hale, bei Neuenhaus, Sachsen-Anhalt]]
#[[Хале, bei Neuenhaus, Sachsen-Anhalt]]
#[[Halle (bei Neuenhaus, Sachsen-Anhalt)]]
#[[Hale (bei Neuenhaus, Sachsen-Anhalt)]]
#[[Хале (bei Neuenhaus, Sachsen-Anhalt)]]
#[[Halle, bei Neuenhaus, ST]]
#[[Hale, bei Neuenhaus, ST]]
#[[Хале, bei Neuenhaus, ST]]
#[[Halle (bei Neuenhaus, ST)]]
#[[Hale (bei Neuenhaus, ST)]]
#[[Хале (bei Neuenhaus, ST)]]
#[[Halle, bei Neuenhaus, ST, Nemačka]]
#[[Hale, bei Neuenhaus, ST, Nemačka]]
#[[Хале, bei Neuenhaus, ST, Nemačka]]
#[[Halle (bei Neuenhaus, ST, Deutschland)]]
#[[Hale (bei Neuenhaus, ST, Deutschland)]]
#[[Хале (bei Neuenhaus, ST, Deutschland)]]
Please note that this is different to the [[#Reverts|case above]] (which was about 2 towns named Halle, but both located in the same state, Lower Saxony).
 
As already explained in the deletion requests (see [https://sh.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Halle,_bei_Neuenhaus,_Saksonija-Anhalt&oldid=40865005]), the problem here is, that the redirects combine 2 completely unrelated locations in their titles. They include '''Neuenhaus in Saxony-Anhalt''' in various forms. Therefore, they suggest that such a location would be real. But it is not. A municipality named Neuenhaus '''does not exist at all''' in Saxony-Anhalt.
 
What happened? Obviously the following two municipalities have been mixed up once in the past:
*[[Halle (bei Neuenhaus)]] in the state of Lower Saxony (= [[Donja Saksonija]] = Niedersachsen = NI) ''– actually near Neuenhaus but NOT in Saxony-Anhalt''
*[[Halle (Saale)]] in the state of Saxony-Anhalt (= [[Saksonija-Anhalt]] = Sachsen-Anhalt = ST) ''– actually in Saxony-Anhalt but NOT near Neuenhaus''
 
So the creation of 30 misleading and implausible redirects (originally to one of the "Halle" articles) was a mistake. No problem, it's easy to correct mistakes on Wikipedia. In this case, correction can only mean deletion, because it really makes no sense to manifest wrong information by keeping false redirects forever.
 
Otherwise – if you want to follow this scheme – you would have to create hundreds of redirects from fantasy location combinations to the disambiguation Halle:
*There are more states of Germany without a municipality named Neuenhaus, e.g. Bavaria. So [[Halle, bei Neuenhaus, Bavarska|Halle, '''bei Neuenhaus, Bavarska''']] or the variant [[Хале, bei Neuenhaus, BY, Nemačka|Хале, '''bei Neuenhaus, BY''', Nemačka]] would be as good (or bad) as the 30 redirects above.
*The administrative structure of Germany with many similar names might be confusing, I know. So maybe the UK capital [[London]] is a better example: <br />A standard redirect from [[London, England, United Kingdom]] would be ok (at least on sh.wikipedia), because London is actually located in the English part of the UK.<br />But redirects from [[London, Scotland, UK|London, '''Scotland''', UK]] or [[London, Wales, UK|London, '''Wales''', UK]] would NOT be ok (factually wrong, as London is neither located in Scotland nor in Wales, even if both are parts of the UK). Such redirects are generally unwanted (probably on sh.wikipedia, too).
 
I hope, I was able to explain the issue and you see the point now. Could you please reconsider deletion of the 30 redirects? Thanks --[[Korisnik:Te750iv|Te750iv]] ([[Razgovor sa korisnikom:Te750iv|razgovor]]) 20:16, 6 januar 2019 (CET)
192

izmjene